To understand what happened needs some record with the Barrymore Awards’ history

Been of the Movies Alliance out of Greater Philadelphia in the 1994-95 seasons, the fresh Alliance very first used nominators chosen throughout the cinema people in order to , new Alliance switched from this effortless system to a-two-tiered method out of 40 in order to fifty nominators and you will ten so you’re able to 17 evaluator, the latter handpicked theatre experts who designed a good device having various of several years of cinema-creating and movies-going feel between him or her.

Within 24 hours shortly after enjoying an eligible let you know, for every single voter logged onto a website to blog post their results to possess each of the applicable prizes (by way of example, “outstanding actor for the a gamble”)

Which today-discarded two-tiered system at random assigned six nominators observe for each eligible manufacturing within the basic three days of their opening evening. Within 24 hours, per completed a vote, giving either a “thumbs-up” or “thumbs-down” for each appropriate category (such as for example “an excellent music recommendations”).

If at least three out of your own half dozen nominators provided an effective thumbs-up in any one classification, next you to creation turned eligible for nomination in almost any class. To determine and that aspects of a show (or no) will be found good nomination, every evaluator now ran and seen that particular creation. After the season, the brand new evaluator-that has seen the eligible design-after that voted for the prizes. The big four vote-getters received nominations, to your champ influenced by and therefore inform you/performer/designer earned one particular of your judges’ ballots.

On 2008-09 year, Margie Silvante, new Cinema Alliance’s new Government Movie director, chose to get rid of the several-tiered system out of nominators and you may evaluator, and you may change it having a great cadre out-of “voters”. Armed with good metrics-dependent amount of quantification, the girl the new system at random tasked 8 voters (out of a swimming pool from 62) to see per inform you, with each voter weighing-in upon twelve to help you 20 designs out of one’s 130 qualified to receive said.

Two competing hypotheses is also define which phenomenon; neither enjoys almost anything to perform with artistic merit

This new web site’s ballot ranged off 0-20 (poor) to 86-one hundred (outstanding), and each voter throw a certain number rating for every possible prize, using these groups such as “poor” once the crude-and-able criteria to compliment their scoring. Under brand new system, the top five score in virtually any award calculated the fresh nominations, towards the finest-area scorer eventually winning this new award (getting announced within service into the October 5).

At the beginning of 2008, Silvante announced these change within a mid-12 months conference regarding nominators and judges and you will troubled this lady desire to reintroduce stability toward procedure and you will take away the prejudice of some judges. I had witnessed this bias within a young fulfilling whenever upcoming-legal Alan Blumenthal accepted in order to Walnut Street Theatre’s Artistic Director Bernard Havard the brand new judges’ early in the day bias resistant to the Walnut’s projects.

Silvante wished you to this lady the latest metrics-created program would eliminate so it unfairness and permit higher rigor by unveiling an approach to quantification that will (in principle) draw on new commonalities regarding judgment from a more impressive and diverse pond off voters.

But rather than just build greater stability and you will rigor, the fresh new process alternatively yielded an effective clustering from nominations unseen into the early in the day years.

To understand what took place, check out the the fresh system’s means of assigning voters. Away from 62 randomly tasked voters, the possibility that any 7 of those saw just one reveal involves 1 in 136 trillion. The chance that one unmarried group of seven voters reunited so you can pick another manufacturing quantity to just one inside the 1.8 x ten twenty seven . (The actual amount are some less by the cover set toward you can easily level of reveals assigned to each person voter.)

Under the old system, the chance that any grouping out-of judges not merely most of the noticed a comparable projects however, saw all the eligible design: 100 percent. The brand new judges you may compare activities, and you will and therefore made certain a level of measured meditation and quality control that the new program does not have.

دیدگاهتان را بنویسید

نشانی ایمیل شما منتشر نخواهد شد.

سوالی دارید؟
مکالمه را شروع کنید
سلام! چگونه می توانیم با پشتیبانی تیم نی نی شینا کمکتون کنیم؟
لطفا برای دریافت پاسخ پشتیبان صبر کنید...